IN THE WORKS: Gentleman's Study

I have a couple of new design projects in the works having now finished up Christine and Will's condo.  First off is a study for the husband of a friend.  The idea is masculine and clubby without falling down the Restoration Hardware rabbit hole (which my client admits to having done in the past).  It's a one room project so it's nice and easy to wrap my head around.  The layout will be as per the below.

And I've come up with two options. I like them both. Option 1 is a little more traditional.

While Option 2 is a little more eclectic.

Which are you partial to? We can't go wrong with either although I personally am a fan of Option 2.